The Boy Who Ate Dog Biscuits

February 1, 1989
Gr 2-4- -A disjointed story about the summer days of a soon-to-be-third-grader who wants a dog. Plot development is fragmented and illogical at times. The inconsistent characterization of the parents sends mixed messages about their son, whom they think needs improvement before he is allowed to have a pet. Billy is a likable, regular kid, and one whom other kids would like to know. His parents call him "irresponsible," but all summer they have trusted him to walk blocks, cross at the light, and spend his free time with the local veterinarian, exercising her strays. When Billy's grandfather comes to visit, he see the responsible side of his grandson, and Billy's favorite stray is brought home to him. Young readers may accept the parental incongruities as normal, but the book is unnecessary in most library collections. -Ellen Dibner, East School, Long Beach, NY

January 1, 2006
Billy would rather have a dog than a new baby sister. Once Billy's grandfather teaches him about helping with the baby, Billy's parents agree that he is responsible enough for a dog, too. This pleasant, short chapter book has a fast plot, realistic situations, and enough expressive illustrations to satisfy the intended audience.

(Copyright 2006 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)